Quran & Panj Surah
Seerah

Chapter 24

Leadership

Background

Rasulullah sallallahu alaihi wasallam ki qayadat sirf fatah ke lamhon mein nahin, balki nuksan, khauf aur mushkil muahidon mein bhi samne aati hai. Uhud mein safon ka imtihan hua, Khandaq mein Madinah ko gherne wali quwwaton ka samna tha, aur Hudaybiyah mein foran ziyarat ki tamanna ke bawajood sulh ka rasta ikhtiyar hua. In waqiat mein jazbati naron ke bajaye faisle, zimmedari aur anjam par nazar rakhna seekhne ko milta hai.

Quran, Surah Aal Imran 3:159 mein narmi, maafi, maghfirat ki dua, mamlaat mein mashwara aur azm ke baad Allah par tawakkul ki hidayat deta hai. Neeche Quran aur sahih ahadith ko bunyadi daleel banaya gaya hai. Seerah ki tareekhi tartib alag pehchan ke saath aati hai. Hubab ibn Mundhir se mansoob mashhoor jangji mashware ko yahan sahih hadith keh kar istemal nahin kiya gaya. Guftagu jahan hai uska Roman Urdu mafhoom diya gaya hai.

Poora Waqiya

Uhud mein hukm aur uske baad

Uhud, jo seerah ki mashhoor tareekhi tartib mein hijrat ke teesre saal hua, mushkil qayadat ka ek gehra sabaq hai. Sahih Bukhari 3039 mein Bara ibn Azib ki riwayat hai ke Nabi ne Abdullah ibn Jubayr ko pachas teer andazon par muqarrar kiya. Hukm ka mafhoom tha: Apni jagah na chhorna jab tak mera paigham na aaye, chahe tum hamein fatah ya sakht nuksan ki haalat mein dekho. Is zimmedari ka maqsad jang ke ek aham morche ko mehfooz rakhna tha.

Jab dushman ki paspaai nazar aayi to kuch teer andazon ne maal e ghanimat ki taraf jane ki baat ki. Abdullah ibn Jubayr ne Nabi ka hukm yaad dilaya, lekin aksar apni jagah se chale gaye. Phir surat e haal badli aur Musalmanon ko sakht nuksan hua. Riwayat mein hukm ki wazahat aur uski khilaf warzi ke asar dono samne aate hain. Qayadat ka sabaq sirf hukm dena nahin, balki aham zimmedari ko ghair mubham rakhna bhi hai.

Quran 3:152 us marhale mein kamzori, ikhtilaf aur hukm ki khilaf warzi ka zikr karta hai, saath Allah ki maafi bhi bayan karta hai. Isi silsile mein 3:159 narmi aur mashware ki hidayat deta hai. Is rabt ko dekh kar samajh aata hai ke ghalati ki pehchan aur afrad ko dobara jama karna dono zaruri hain. Islah ka matlab nuksan chhupana nahin, aur ehtisab ka matlab har shakhs ko hamesha ke liye zaleel kar dena nahin.

Khandaq mein mushtarka mehnat

Khandaq, ya Ahzab, seerah ki mashhoor tartib mein hijrat ke panchwein saal ka waqia hai. Quran 33:10-11 lashkaron ke dabao aur mominon ki sakht azmaish ka zikr karta hai. Sahih Bukhari 4104 mein Bara bayan karte hain ke Nabi khandaq ki khudai ke dauran mitti utha rahe the, yahan tak ke mitti ne Aap ke pait ko dhak diya. Is sahih manzar mein qaid sirf doosron ko mehnat ka hukm dene wala nahin, khud mehnat mein shareek hai.

Khandaq ke mashware ki nisbat Salman Farsi ki taraf seerah mein mashhoor hai; ise Ibn Hisham ki seerati naql ke darje mein samajhna chahiye, na ke is Bukhari ki riwayat ka lafz. Yahan bunyadi sahih gawahi mushtarka khudai aur Nabi ki amali shirkat hai. Tareekhi riwayat ko uske darje par rakhne se qisse ki qadr kam nahin hoti, lekin qari ke liye daleel ka maqam wazeh rehta hai.

Jab tamam log dabao mein hon to qaid ka apne liye mukhtalif araam talab karna safon mein doori paida kar sakta hai. Mitti uthana ek zahiri, sabit amal hai; hum iske saath har sahabi ka ghair manqool jazbati jawab nahin jorte. Is se aaj ke zimmedar ko yeh rehnumai milti hai ke mushkil mansube mein zimmedari, mehnat aur zarurat ke bojh se khud ko mustasna na samjhe. Tawakkul asbab chhorna nahin: khandaq khodna bhi tadbeer thi.

Hudaybiyah ka mushkil muahida

Hudaybiyah ki tafseeli sahih riwayat Sahih Bukhari 2731-2732 mein hai. Musalman umrah ke irade se aaye the, lekin Quraysh ne rasta roka. Muzakrat ke baad Suhayl ibn Amr ke saath sharaait tay hone lagin. Tehreer ke alfaaz par bhi ikhtilaf hua. Nabi ne sulh ke maqsad ko samne rakhte hue aisi lafzi tabdili qabool ki jo apni risalat ke haq hone se dastbardari nahin thi. Har sakht lafzi mutalabe ko foran jang ka sabab nahin banaya gaya.

Isi dauran Abu Jandal, jo Suhayl ke bete the, bandishon mein Musalmanon ke paas pahunche. Unka maamla sahabah ke liye bohat sakht tha. Riwayat ke mutabiq unhein muahide ki shart ke tahat wapas karna pada. Is manzar ko asaan ya be dard faisla kehna durust nahin, lekin Nabi ne muahide aur jamaat ke wasee anjam ko nazarandaz nahin kiya. Hum Abu Jandal ya sahabah ke dil ki woh tafseel nahin likhte jo riwayat ne bayan nahin ki.

Sulh ke baad Nabi ne sahabah ko qurbani aur sar mundwane ka hukm diya. Riwayat batati hai ke teen martaba kehne ke bawajood foran koi na utha. Aap Umm Salamah raziyallahu anha ke paas gaye aur is haalat ka zikr kiya. Unka mashwara mafhoom yeh tha: Bahar tashrif le jayein, kisi se kuch kahe baghair apni qurbani karein aur apne sar ke baal mundwayein. Nabi ne aisa kiya, phir sahabah bhi uth kar apne manasik ada karne lage.

Yahan mashwara ek ahliya se liya gaya aur uski munasib rai par amal hua. Qayadat apne mansab ko mashware ki zarurat se bala tar nahin samajhti. Umm Salamah ne logon ko zalil karne ya bar bar sakht taqreer karne ke bajaye amal ki misaal pesh karne ka rasta bataya. Is se har surat e haal ke liye ek hi formula nahin nikalta, lekin yeh wazeh hota hai ke rukawat ko samajhne aur uska rasta nikalne mein mukhtalif nazariye mufeed hote hain.

Surah al Fath 48:1 mein roshan fatah ka elan aata hai. Hudaybiyah ka waqia sikhata hai ke kisi faisle ko sirf us lamhe ki na pasandidgi se nahin parakha jata. Saath hi is se har siyasi samjhaute ko khud bakhud nabawi sulh keh dena bhi durust nahin. Aaj kisi muahide ki sharait, insaf, zimmedari aur mumkin nuksanat ko khule taur par jaanchna hoga; muqaddas waqie ka naam daleel ki jagah nahin le sakta.

Sabaq

  1. Uhud mein wazeh hidayat aur uski pabandi ki ahmiyat samne aati hai. Team ko maqsad batana, zimmedar afrad muqarrar karna aur tabdeeli ka ikhtiyar wazeh rakhna zaruri hai. Nakami ke baad ghalati pehchani jaye, magar logon ki wapsi aur behtari ka darwaza band na ho. Quran ki maafi aur mashware ki hidayat is tawazun ko mazboot karti hai.
  2. Khandaq mein shareek mehnat aur Hudaybiyah mein Umm Salamah ka mashwara batata hai ke qayadat tanha zaheen hone ka naam nahin. Kabhi qaid ko mitti uthani hoti hai, kabhi dhyan se sunna hota hai, aur kabhi sab se pehle khud amal karna hota hai. Kisi rai ki qadr bolne wale ki jins ya ghar ke rishtay ki wajah se kam nahin ho jati.
  3. Tawakkul faisle se pehle tahqiq aur mashware ko mansookh nahin karta. Quran 3:159 mein mashwara, azm aur tawakkul ek tarteeb mein aate hain. Inhein samajhna zimmedari se bachne ke bajaye zimmedari qabool karna sikhata hai. Hum natije par mukammal qaboo nahin rakhte, lekin daleel, adal aur diyanat ke mutabiq koshish ke jawabdeh hain.

Aaj Ka Amal

Agle aham gharelu ya idari faisle se pehle masla ek jumle mein likhein. Mutasir afrad se rai lein, khas taur par unse jo aam tor par nahin bol pate. Maloom haqaiq, andaze aur na maloom pehlu alag karein. Phir zimmedar shakhs, muddat aur dobara jaize ka waqt tay karein. Yeh amali tareeqa hai, koi manqool nabawi jadwal nahin.

Kisi purani nakami par ek mukhtasar, beizzati se pak jaiza karein: kya hukm ghair wazeh tha, zaraye kam the, ya hidayat ki pabandi nahin hui? Har sawal ka saboot dekhein aur ek islah tay karein. Mushkil faisle mein mukhalif rai sunne wale ko dushman na banayein; lekin faisla hone ke baad jaiz zimmedari se farar ko bhi mashware ka naam na dein.